Senate Republican leaders unveiled a new version of their health-care bill on Thursday after the first version failed to get enough support. The bill takes major steps to roll back provisions of the Affordable Care Act, with spending cuts to Medicaid and marketplace subsidies funding a substantial tax cut for the health-care industry.
Compared to the previous bill, it provides fewer tax breaks for the rich, and uses that money to increase funding for high-cost patients, among other things. It also includes an amendment offered by Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), which would allow companies to sell cheaper, bare-bones plans alongside more comprehensive ACA-compliant ones.
A vote could come within the next few weeks. If it passes, it would need to be reconciled with the House’s bill before going to President Trump’s desk.
[McConnell to release new GOP health plan allowing bare-bones insurance policies]
See what the Senate bill changes about the ACA and the House bill, including all the latest changes marked according to whether they appeal to moderates or appeal to conservatives:
Who would be covered
Under Senate Republicans’ plan, the government would no longer penalize Americans for failing to have health insurance.
ACA
HOUSE BILL
SENATE BILL
ACA
The individual mandate requires most Americans to have health coverage or pay a fine.
HOUSE BILL
Instead of the mandate, insurers would be allowed to impose a 30 percent premium surcharge on consumers who purchase a new plan after letting their previous coverage lapse — incentivizing healthy people to remain insured. States could choose to make this penalty more severe.
SENATE BILL
Instead of the mandate, people who had a break in coverage would have to wait six months before getting new coverage, incentivizing healthy people to stay in the market. Being on a bare-bones plan, as allowed by Cruz’s amendment, counts as a break in coverage.
ACA
The employer mandate requires larger companies to offer affordable coverage to their employees.
HOUSE BILL
The employer mandate would be eliminated.
SENATE BILL
The employer mandate would be eliminated.
ACA
Young adults could stay on their parents’ health insurance plan until they’re 26 years old.
HOUSE BILL
This provision was unchanged.
SENATE BILL
This provision was unchanged.
How they would pay for coverage
The federal health insurance subsidies that help most people with ACA marketplace plans afford their coverage would change. Health care would get substantially less affordable for most of these people, especially those who are poor, unhealthy or old, according to Linda Blumberg of the Urban Institute, Christine Eibner of Rand Corp. and Karen Pollitz of the Kaiser Family Foundation.
ACA
HOUSE BILL
SENATE BILL
ACA
ACA tax credits are primarily based on income, age and geography, which benefits lower- and moderate-income people buying coverage through ACA marketplaces.
HOUSE BILL
Tax credits would be based primarily on age. The amount would not increase when premiums increased, and people living in higher-cost areas would receive no additional money.
SENATE BILL
Tax credits would be primarily based on age, income and geography. But, they could cover a narrower plan, and people would need to make less money than under the ACA to receive them.
ACA
Cost-sharing subsidies were provided to insurers to help some of their ACA customers cover deductibles and co-payments.
HOUSE BILL
These subsidies would end in 2020, although Trump could cut them off earlier.
SENATE BILL
These subsidies would end in 2020, although Trump could cut them off earlier.
ACA
Insurance companies are not allowed to increase someone’s premiums or deny coverage based on preexisting conditions.
HOUSE BILL
States could allow insurers to increase someone’s premiums based on their preexisting conditions if they had a break in coverage. The state would have to set up some other program, such as a high-risk pool, to cover its sickest residents. And the federal government would have its own $8 billion fund to help cover sick people’s high premiums within the individual market.
SENATE BILL
Insurance companies are not allowed to increase someone’s premiums or deny coverage based on preexisting conditions, though states may allow them to not cover costs associated with some conditions. Cruz’s amendment would allow insurance companies to consider preexisting conditions when charging customers, as long as they also offer at least one plan that doesn’t. Experts expect this to drive up costs for sicker people.
ACA
Insurers can charge older customers up to three times as much as they charge younger customers.
HOUSE BILL
Insurers would be able to charge older customers up to five times as much as they charge younger customers. States could change this ratio, although it’s unclear whether it could be higher than 5 to 1.
SENATE BILL
Insurers would be able to charge older customers up to five times as much as they charge younger customers.
ACA
Individuals can contribute up to $3,400 and families up to $6,750 to pretax health savings accounts.
HOUSE BILL
Starting in 2018, individuals could contribute up to $6,550 and families could contribute up to $13,100 to pretax health savings accounts.
SENATE BILL
People can contribute more to their health savings accounts than under the ACA. People could also begin to use their HSAs to pay for premiums.
ACA
The ACA did not create high-risk pools, because there were other protections for pre-existing conditions.
HOUSE BILL
States would receive $130 billion over 10 years through a new Patient and State Stability Fund for high-risk pools and other programs to help sicker people.
SENATE BILL
The stability fund would receive $182 billion over 10 years and would be aimed at reimbursing insurers who take big losses. This is $70 billion higher than the previous version of the bill. The new bill also adds $45 billion to address the opioid epidemic.
Proposed changes to Medicaid
The bill would restructure Medicaid, narrow the program’s eligibility and probably decrease its funding.
ACA
HOUSE BILL
SENATE BILL
ACA
Medicaid is an entitlement program with open-ended, matching federal funds for anyone who qualifies.
HOUSE BILL
Medicaid would be funded by giving states a per capita amount or block grant based on how much each state is spending, not adjusting for rising costs. Overall, this is expected to substantially decrease federal funding, according to the Congressional Budget Office’s report on the plan.
SENATE BILL
Medicaid would be funded by giving states a per capita amount or block grant, beginning in 2021. The amount would grow more slowly than in the House bill, meaning bigger spending cuts overall. The new version of the bill allows states to go over this cap in the case of public health emergencies.
ACA
States can expand Medicaid to cover people making up to 138 percent of the poverty line, and the federal government would cover an outsize portion of their costs.
HOUSE BILL
States would not be able to expand Medicaid after this year. In states that do expand by the deadline, the federal government will pay a smaller portion of the cost for people who sign up after 2019, making the expansion much more expensive for those states.
SENATE BILL
For states that expand Medicaid, the federal government would pay a smaller portion of the cost starting in 2021.
Other key elements of the plans
ACA
HOUSE BILL
SENATE BILL
ACA
Insurers are required to cover certain categories of essential health benefits, such as hospital visits and mental-health care.
HOUSE BILL
States would be allowed to change what qualifies as an essential health benefit.
SENATE BILL
States would be allowed to change what qualifies as an essential health benefit. Under Cruz’s amendment, insurance companies will be able to sell bare-bones plans, as long as they also offer at least one that’s comprehensive. Experts expect this to drive up costs for sicker people.
ACA
Planned Parenthood is eligible for Medicaid reimbursements, but federal money cannot fund abortions.
HOUSE BILL
Planned Parenthood would face a one-year Medicaid funding freeze.
SENATE BILL
Planned Parenthood would face a one-year Medicaid funding freeze.
ACA
Caps on annual or lifetime coverage are banned for essential health benefits.
HOUSE BILL
The ban on caps itself is not changing, but because states could narrow what qualifies as an essential health benefit, more types of care could face caps.
SENATE BILL
The ban on caps itself is not changing, but states could opt out of the ban.
More stories
Where the Obamacare exchanges might have zero insurers in 2018
Many have said they’ll leave the marketplaces, citing rising costs and Trump-fueled uncertainty.
Which GOP senators have concerns with the health-care bill
Only three Republican senators need to vote against the bill for it to fail.
What’s next for the GOP health-care bill
A guide to Republicans’ plan to “repeal and replace” Obamacare.